Menu
Main
Appetizers
The Best Bruschetta
$7.75Garlic toast with chopped tomatoes, fresh mushrooms, and chopped onions. All topped with oregano and Romano cheese. Served with a side ofย sauce.Add Mozzarella Cheese +$1.50Add Extra Side of Sauce +$0.75
Soup
Big Mike's Beans & Greens
Our hats off to Michael's on Pine Avenue in the Falls for his original version of this great Italianย dish!Cup $3.75Bowl $4.50Quart $8
Salads
Dressings Choose: Balsamic Vinaigrette, Bleu Cheese, Caesar, Creamy Italian, French, Honey Mustard, Italian, Oil & Vinegar, Peppercorn Ranch, Ranch, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Russian. Crumbly Blue +$.35 | Extra 2oz Cup Dressing +$.50 | Change to Romaine Lettuceย +$1.25
Antipasto
Complete chef's salad with black & green olives, ham, capicola, salami & provoloneย cheeseSmall $8.50Large $14.50
Caesar Salad
A bed of fresh romaine topped with homemade croutons & Romanoย cheeseSmall $7Large $9
Chicken Caesar
A bed of fresh romaine topped with homemade croutons. Romano cheese & freshly grilledย chickenSmall $9Large $11
Chef's Salad
Iceberg lettuce topped with carrots, tomatoes, cucumber, chic peas & homemadeย croutonsSmall $5.25Large $7.50
Julienne
Complete chef's salad topped with freshly sliced Turkey, Ham & provolone cheese and homemadeย croutonsSmall $7.25Large $10.40
Sandwiches
Add French Fries +$1.50 | Add Onion Ringsย +$1.50
Famous Ranch Burger
$12The original version created over 60 years ago by John Dickinson of Fredonia, NY! Consists of a cheeseburger; hamburger, lettuce, tomato and secret sauce, add a slice of onion to capture the best of this classic. Once you have tried one, you will be hooked forย life!
Homemade Meatball Sandwich
$10Open Faced with homemade sauce on homemadeย breadAdd Mozzarella Cheese +$1.50
Subs
Choose White or Wheat. Most Come with Lettuce, Tomato and Cheese.ย
Additional Toppings: Onions, Ketchup, Mayo, Oil, Mustard.ย
Toppings Add +$.50: Mushrooms, Extra Tomatoes, Bleu Cheese.ย
Toppings Add +$.75 Sweet Peppers, Banana Peppers.ย
Toppings Add +.88 Black Olives, Green Olives.ย
Toppings Add +$1.50 Extraย Bacon
Specialty Subs
Choose White or Wheat. Toppings: Onions, Ketchup, Mayo, Oil, Mustard. Toppings Add +$.50: Mushrooms, Extra Tomatoes, Bleu Cheese. Toppings Add +$.75 Sweet Peppers, Banana Peppers. Toppings Add +.88 Black Olives, Green Olives. Toppings Add +$1.50 Extraย Bacon
4 Cheese Steak Melt
Tender shaved steak with hot peppers & mushrooms, smothered in mozzarella, Romano, Monterey Jack & cheddarย cheese.6" $8.9512" $11.95
Chicken and Spinach
Pasta sauce, chicken, spinach with herbs & spices topped with melted mozzarellaย cheese6" $8.9512" $11.95
Country Club Sub
Salami, ham & turkey with bacon & provolone cheese on a bed of lettuce &ย tomatoes6" $8.9512" $11.95
Steak and Ring
Freshly grilled steak with golden brown onion rings topped with melted mozzarella cheese, served with fresh lettuce &ย tomatoes6" $8.9512" $11.95
Steak and Spinach
Freshly grilled steak with our homemade spinach blend, garlic butter & mozzarellaย cheese6" $8.9512" $11.95
Steak Delight
Freshly grilled steak with mushrooms, garlic butter and mozzarellaย cheese6" $8.9512" $11.95
Steak Supreme Sub
Toasted roll with melted mozzarella, grilled shaved steak, fried sweet peppers, mushrooms andย onions.6" $8.9512" $11.95
Wraps & Baked Burritos
Choose for sauce: Hot | Medium | Mild | Plain. Add +$.50 each: Extra Cheese, Sour Cream. Add extra +$.75 Banana Peppers, Sweet Peppers. Add +$.88 each: Green Olives, Blackย Olives.
Choose Wrap: Garlic Herb | Jalapeรฑo | No Wrap | Spinach | Flourย Tortilla.
Beef Burrito
$6.95Served with tex-mex meat, cheddar & jack cheeses. Not served withย chips.
Chicken Burrito
$6.95Served with grilled chicken & mozzarella cheese. Not served withย chips.
Chicken Fajita Wrap
$12Tender chicken strips on a bed of lettuce and tomato with sweet peppers, onions, taco sauce and cheddarย cheese.
Chicken Caesar Wrap
$11Tender chicken, romaine lettuce, shaved parmesan cheese and Caesarย Dressing
Chicken Wings & Fingers
Chicken Wings Choose Regular Wings or Boneless Wings. Wings Extras: Finish Wings in Brick Oven +$1.00 | Side Bleu Cheese +$0.95 | (2) Sides of Bleu Cheese +$1.90 | (3) Sides of Bleu Cheese +$2.85 | All Drums +$0.75| All Flats +$0.75 | On the Grillย +$1.
Chicken Finger Options: Side Bleu Cheese +$0.95 | (2) Sides of Bleu Cheese +$1.90 | (3) Sides of Bleu Cheese +$2.85| Xtra Celeryย +$0.50
Combo Specials
Pizza Toppings: Anchovies, Bacon, Black Olives, Garlic, Green Olives, Ham, Hamburger Meat, Hot Peppers, Italian Sausage, Meatball, Mushrooms, No Toppings, Onions, Pepperoni, Pineapple, Sweet Peppers. Add Artichoke Hearts, +$1.65, Broccoli +$1.65, Chicken +$1.65, Extra Cheese +$1.65, Spinach +$1.65, Steakย +$1.65.
Choose 2 Liter: Coke | Diet Coke | Sprite | Gingerย Ale
COMBO SPECIAL: Single Order (10 Wings), Small 1 Item Pizza & 2 Liter Pop
$25.25Combo Special First Pizza toppingย FREE.
COMBO SPECIAL: The 15 Combo
$38.25Large Sicilian Pizza (15 Slices) with Cheese & 1 Topping and Triple Order (15 Fingers) of Chicken Fingers with Fries and Blueย Cheese.Around the World Pizza +$7.70BBQ Chicken Pizza +$7.70Chicken Finger Pizza +$7.70Classic White +$7.70Desperate Housewife +$7.70Four Cheese Steak +$7.70Garden Veggie +$7.70Hawaiian +$7.70Manhattan Mediterranean +$7.70NY Style Thin Crust Cheese +$7.70Southern Italy Pie +$7.70Spinach Supreme +$7.70Steak n' Ring +$7.70Supreme +$7.70Tex Mex +$7.70White Chicken Broccoli +$7.70
Calzones
Extra Side of Sauceย +$0.75
Chicken and Broccoli Calzone
(Paul's Pick) Our fresh dough stuffed with ricotta cheese, grilled chicken strips, broccoli, mozzarella, Monterey Jack & Cheddarย Cheese12" $13.7517" $18
Create Your Own Calzone
Our fresh dough stuffed with ricotta cheese, homemade sauce & mozzarellaย cheese12" $1217" $1627" $27.95
Wood Fired Brick Oven Pizza
#1 Hey Tony, It's Pepperoni
$14.50The classic cheese and pepperoni on our freshly prepared famous redย sauce.
#2 Old Fashioned Italian
$14.25Heavy red sauce topped with basil, oregano, and pecorino romanoย cheese.
#3 Native New Yorker
$14.50Sliced tomatoes and fresh basil on top of red sauce and freshย mozzarella.
#4 San Francisco
$15Sun-dried tomatoes, artichoke hearts, fresh mushrooms and mozzarella cheese on a white garlic crust brushed with Extra Virgin Oliveย Oil.
#5 Smokin' Joe
$16.50Sliced green olives and onions with pepperoncini, Italian sausage and bacon, red sauce, mozzarella and smoked Goudaย cheese.
#6 Miami Beach
$15.25An oil/garlic brushed base with sliced tomatoes, grilled chicken, and broccoli with meltedย mozzarella.
#7 Pesto Provolone
$15.25Fresh mushrooms, homemade spinach mix, artichoke hearts, sliced tomatoes and a provolone-mozzarella cheese blend on a crust lightly brushed withย pesto.
#8 Manhattan Mediterranean
$15.50(Winner of the 2009 "Buffalo Pizza Fest" Best Gourmet Pizza Award!) -- Grilled chicken, sliced artichoke hearts and tomatoes with mozzarella on a pesto base, all lightly topped with asiagoย cheese.
#9 Spinach Supreme
$15.50Our homemade spinach mix on ricotta cheese base with ripe black olives. juicy mushrooms and all lightly topped with mozzarella cheese, pecorino, romano andย oregano.
#10 Belly Dancer
$16.50A pesto base covered with mozzarella cheese, artichoke hearts, sun dried tomatoes, sliced banana peppers, a mixture of gorgonzola and asiago cheeses with roasted pine nuts andย oregano.
Specialty Pizza
Angel's Delight
Homemade dough topped with oil, garlic, mozzarella and Romano cheese with pasta sauce on theย side.Small 13 in. Round (8 Slice) $14.75Large 17 in. Round (12 Slice) $20.50Large 17 in. X 13 in. Sicilian (15 Slice) $20.50Party 26 in. x 17 in. Sicilian (30 Slice) $39.50
Around The World
Mozzarella cheese and pepperoni (US), Italian sausage (Italy), green olives (Ireland) and hot peppersย (Mexico).Small 13 in. Round (8 Slice) $17.50Large 17 in. Round (12 Slice) $23.95Large 17 in. x 13 in. Sicilian (15 Slice) $23.95Party 26 in. x 17 in. Sicilian (30 Slice) $46.50
Chicken Finger
Small 13 in. Round (8 Slice) $17.50Large 17 in. Round (12 Slice) $23.95Large 17 in. x 13 in. Sicilian (15 Slice) $23.95Party 26 in. x 17 in. Sicilian (30 Slice) $46.50
Classic White Pizza
Mozzarella and romano cheeses, mushrooms, tomatoes, onions, extra virgin olive oil andย garlic.Small 13 in. Round (8 Slice) $17.50Large 17 in. Round (12 Slice) $23.95Large 17 in. x 13 in. Sicilian (15 Slice) $23.95Party 26 in. x 17 in. Sicilian (30 Slice) $46.50
Desperate Housewife
Extra virgin olive oil, tender grilled chicken strips, hot peppers and spinach. All covered with mozzarella cheese on a garlicย crust.Small 13 in. Round (8 Slice) $17.50Large 17 in. Round (12 Slice) $23.95Large 17 in. x 13 in. Sicilian (15 Slice) $23.95Party 26 in. x 17 in. Sicilian (30 Slice) $46.50
Four Cheese Steak
Steak, hot peppers and mushrooms covered in a blend of mozzarella, cheddar, Romano and Monterey Jack Cheeses. All on an oil & garlicย crust.Small 13 in. Round (8 Slice) $22.25Large 17 in. Round (12 Slice) $29.50Large 17 in. x 13 in. Sicilian (15 Slice) $29.50Party 26 in. x 17 in. Sicilian (30 Slice) $46.50
Garden Veggie Pizza
Broccoli, tomatoes, mushrooms and mozzarella cheese on a white garlicย crust.Small 13 in. Round (8 Slice) $17.50Large 17 in. Round (12 Slice) $23.95Large 17 in. x 13 in. (15 Slice) Sicilian $23.95Party 26 in. x 17 in. Sicilian (30 Slice) $46.50
Hawaiian Pizza
Cheese, ham andย pineapple.Small 13 in. Round (8 Slice) $14.75Large 17 in. Round (12 Slice) $20.50Large 17 in. x 13 in. Sicilian (15 Slice) $20.50Party 26 in. x 17 in. Sicilian (30 Slice) $39.50
Southern Italy Pie
Olive oil, garlic, mozzarella cheese, loads of steak cooked to perfection, spinach, mushrooms andย onions.Small 13 in. Round (8 Slice) $22.25Large 17 in. Round (12 Slice) $29.50Large 17 in. x 13 in. Sicilian (15 Slice) $23.95Party 26 in. x 17 in. Sicilian (30 Slice) $46.50
Steak n' Ring Pizza
Mozzerella cheese, strips of shaved steak, golden brown onion rings, oil & garlic, topped withย cheddar.Small 13 in. Round (8 Slice) $17.50Large 17 in. Round (12 Slice) $23.95Large 17 in. x 13 in. Sicilian (15 Slice) $23.95Party 26 in. x 17 in. Sicilian (30 Slice) $46.50
BBQ Chicken Bacon
Small 13 in. Round (8 Slice) $18.50Large 17 in. Round (12 Slice) $23.95Large 17 in. x 13 in. Sicilian (15 Slice) $23.95Party 26 in. x 17 in. Sicilian (30 Slice) $46.50
Double Meat Pizza
Small 13 in. Round (8 Slice) $18.50Large 17 in. Round (12 Slice) $23.95Large 17 in. x 13 in. Sicilian (15 Slice) $23.95Party 26 in. x 17 in. Sicilian (30 Slice) $46.50
Old Fashioned
Small 13 in. Round (8 Slice) $12Large 17 in. Round (12 Slice) $20.50Large 17 in. x 13 in. Sicilian (15 Slice) $20.50Party 26 in. x 17 in. Sicilian (30 Slice) $22
Spinach Supreme
Small 13 in. Round (8 Slice) $18.50Large 17 in. Round (12 Slice) $23.95Large 17 in. x 13 in. Sicilian (15 Slice) $23.95Party 26 in. x 17 in. Sicilian (30 Slice) $46.50
Stuffed Pepper
Small 13 in. Round (8 Slice) $18.50Large 17 in. Round (12 Slice) $23.95Large 17 in. x 13 in. Sicilian (15 Slice) $23.95Party 26 in. x 17 in. Sicilian (30 Slice) $46.50
Supreme
Small 13 in. Round (8 Slice) $17.50Large 17 in. Round (12 Slice) $23.95Large 17 in. x 13 in. Sicilian (15 Slice) $23.95Party 26 in. x 17 in. Sicilian (30 Slice) $46.50
Tex Mex
Small 13 in. Round (8 Slice) $18.50Large 17 in. Round (12 Slice) $23.95Large 17 in. x 13 in. Sicilian (15 Slice) $23.95Party 26 in. x 17 in. Sicilian (30 Slice) $46.50
The Manhattan Mediterranean
Pesto sauce base, fresh tomatoes, grilled chicken, artichoke hearts, mozzarella and Asiagoย cheese.Small 13 in. Round (8 Slice) $17.50Large 17 in. Round (12 Slice) $23.95Large 17 in. x 13 in. Sicilian (15 Slice) $23.95Party 26 in. x 17 in. Sicilian (30 Slice) $46.50
Vegetarian Pizza
Small 13 in. Round (8 Slice) $18.50Large 17 in. Round (12 Slice) $23.95Large 17 in. x 13 in. Sicilian (15 Slice) $23.95Party 26 in. x 17 in. Sicilian (30 Slice) $46.50
Dinners
Soup or Salad Choose: Cup Beans n Greens, Cup Chicken Noodle, Cup Soup of Day, Salad, French Onionย +$.75
Baked Rigatoni Parm
$14.50Served with our Italian pasta sauce and baked covered with mozzarellaย cheese.
BBQ Rib Dinner
Served with (Choice of 2) pasta salad, cole slaw and fries. Does NOT include salad orย bread.Half Rack $14.50Full Rack $22
Chicken Parmesan
$16.95Tender chicken on top of a bed of spaghetti with our homemade sauce and topped with mozzarellaย cheese.
Homemade Lasagna
$18Lasagna baked to perfection! This recipe has been in Paul's family for over 60 years. Our best sellingย dinner!
Eggplant Parm
$15.75Spaghetti covered with our Italian pasta sauce, topped with eggplant and baked with melted mozzarellaย cheese.
Manicotti
$16.95Four manicotti ๏ฌlled with ricotta cheese and Italian spices. Covered with our homemade Italian pastaย sauce.
Shrimp in the Basket
$14.50Breaded butter๏ฌied shrimp; cooked to perfection, served with French fries, chef's salad and homemadeย bread.
Spaghetti Chicken Florentine
$16.95Spaghetti with tender chicken blended with our spinach mixture and butter garlic sauce baked covered inย mozzarella.
Tortellini
$14.50A generous portion of tortellini cooked fresh and served covered in homemadeย sauce.
Variety Pasta
$16.952 manicotti and 3 ravioli on top of a bed of tortellini covered in homemade sauce and meltedย mozzarella.
Wood Fired Gnocchi Parm
$15.75A generous serving of freshly prepared gnocchi covered in homemade sauce and mozzarella cheese, then baked in our Brickย Oven!
Daily Specials
Sunday Pizza & Wings Special
$51.25Large one topping Pizza & 50 Wings with your choice of Buffalo Wingย Sauce.
Monday Lasagna Special
$15.25Our Homemade Lasagna. Includes a dinner salad and homemadeย bread.
Tuesday Burrito Special
$5.50Choose between steak, beef or chicken and add your favoriteย toppings.
Lunch Combos
$7.25 (Monday - Friday only 11am \ 4pm) Add Fries +$1.50. Choose your drink: Coke |Diet Cokeย |
Ginger Ale | Lemonade | Loganberry | Orange | Root Beer | Sprite | Sweetened Iced Tea | Unsweetened Ice Tea | Chocolate Milk | Milk | Appleย Juice
Sides
Desserts
Deep Fried Oreos
Real oreos wrapped by hand in dough, cooked until fluffy hot & sprinkled with powderedย sugar2 $4.50
Fried Dough
$4.95Warm & fluffy strips of our homemade dough sprinkled with powdered sugar &ย cinnamon